Meet Our Team

Cody Coffey

Agency Owner

As a Personal Financial Representative living in Fort Payne for 28 years with my wife Jessica and 2 children. I know many local families. My knowledge and understanding of the people in this community our agency service over 9,200 households with an outstanding level of service. I look forward to helping families like yours protect the things that are important – your family, home, car and more. I’m also here to help you prepare a strategy to achieve your financial goals.

As a small business owner, I understand the importance of building a solid foundation for the future and developing long-lasting customer relationships. That’s why I’m committed to offering you the same level of service I’d expect from my own business dealings. When you leave my office, I hope you’ll feel confident, informed, assured and satisfied in your choices. The way you should feel.


  • Inner Circle: 2 Years
  • Circle Of Champions: 3 Years
  • Leader’s Forum: 3 Years
  • National Conference: 3 Years
  • Honor Ring: 6 Years


Kimberly Fletcher
Sales Producer

Click to Email

Kimberly has worked at Allstate for 19 years and with Coffey Agencies for 12 of those 19 years.  She greatly enjoys working in the Centre location and getting to know everyone in the area. She resides in Etowah County with her husband and their two small dogs.  She has two children and two grandchildren.

We have built a great sales and service team within Coffey Agencies that go above and beyond to help all of our customers with all of their insurance needs.  For Kimberly, she finds working with our customers vastly rewarding, especially when she can save them money on their insurance and educate them on how their coverages work.

Crystal Brozio
Customer Service Manager

Click to Email

Crystal grew up in the small town of Fyffe and graduated in 2013. She is married to her husband, Austin, and they have been together since 2019.  She has two children, Braxley and Kinsley. In her free time, she enjoys outdoor activities such as swimming and riding ATVs. Crystal’s career in the insurance industry started in 2014, and shortly after, she joined the Coffey Agencies team. Her everyday goal and passion are to help people. She is grateful to help assist our team, loyal customers, and the local community.

Heather Boman
Customer Service

Click to Email

Heather was born and raised in Northeast Alabama. She graduated from Pisgah High School in 2013.

As a mother, her precious 5-year-old son is the love of her life, and most of her spare time is spent on fun activities with him.

When Heather was choosing her career path, she knew she wanted to help people and decided insurance was the perfect opportunity. She assures that her customers have what is beneficial for their needs and ensures they save the most money.

Heather’s wish for herself, her customers, and everyone around her is to have confidence.  She always has a smile on her face, and kindness is of the utmost importance to her.

Misty Monroe
Sales Producer

Click to Email

Born and raised in Fort Payne, AL. She and her husband Steve of 36 years have three sons and are currently expecting their second grandchild. While Misty has only recently joined the Cody Coffey Agency, she has already had the pleasure of being one of the top 20 Agents in our region. Her greatest accomplishment is being able to serve & give back to the community she calls home. Her priority is treating her customers like family and being able to help them at any time.

“Trusting your Agent is extremely important & I hope you give me the opportunity to earn that trust.”

Heather Brown
Sales Agent

Click to Email

“Georgia Peach” by birth, and raised in Texas, Heather spent her youth playing sports and running the rodeo circuits. Her early adult years were spent in the Food and Beverage Industry as well as the Medical Field, where her outgoing personality and “go get it” attitude flourished. She takes pride in and LOVES taking care of people, making sure they are happy and have everything they need. Definitely has a servant’s heart! She has recently joined the Coffey Agencies team and is excited to work for and take care of YOU, her customers/friends.  Outside of work, Heather and her husband spend their time traveling all over Alabama, supporting their beautiful daughters in their sports, as well as visiting every off-road mud park in the country!


Kathy Sewell
Customer Service

Click to Email

Kathy has been in the insurance industry for over 10 years and with the Coffey Agencies since March 2020.  She enjoys helping the agency clients understand their family risk and working with them on the best protection.  She is licensed in both Georgia and Alabama and knowledgeable in policies and state regulations.

In her free time, she enjoys spending time with her grandchildren, watching the Atlanta Braves, and working in her container garden.

Harold Cartwright

Sales Producer

Click to Email

Born in Augusta Georgia, raised in Floyd County Georgia, Harold has spent most of his twenties thus far traveling and working in several industries in the Customer Service field. Spending his free time as close as he can get to a body of water a cookout or a kayak.

He has worked in telecommunications, Medical Insurance, and Retail Management for the entirety of his career. The skills accumulated from these diverse industries are what Harold feels will allow him to assist the customers of the Coffey Agency to the highest degree of customer service one should find at their local insurance agency.

After traveling and mentorships Harold decided to move back home to Floyd County Georgia to be more local to family and to continue his career in Customer Service. Shortly thereafter he had the opportunity to join a team he feels is fully dedicated to providing the very best to their customers He is excited to be a part of a team he feels is exceptional.

 Harold looks forward to building long-lasting trusting relationships with the Coffey Agency, and customers alike.

Debbie Cohn
Customer Service Rep

Click to Email

I am originally from Southern California but have lived in North Georgia for over 20 years. Georgia is now home and where I met my husband. We still reside in Pickens County Ga.

I have four beautiful grandchildren who I try to spend as much time with as possible and one rescue fur baby. My free time is always with them or it’s watching football. I know I’m an “outsider” on this, but I still shout GO USC!!!

I have been with insurance for over 15 years and I truly believe insurance is my calling. I have performed in a Customer Service role my entire life. I actually get to use my experience for the pleasure of assisting customers and helping them understand what they really need for the protection of their family and their selves. I’m guilty of having a genuine servant’s heart when it comes to the needs of others.

Jennifer Johnson

Click to Email

Born in North Georgia and raised as a military brat, Jennifer’s loyalty and service to her community and others were instilled in her at a very young age. She obtained her post-secondary education at Shorter University, earning a degree in Business Management (GO HAWKS).  She resides in Cedartown, Georgia, with her husband CJ and their children.  She has formed many personal and professional relationships with the people of Rome and the surrounding areas.

Jennifer takes pride in the work she performs and being knowledgeable of the insurance industry.  Her daily passion is to help properly protect the things families work hard for, and she is grateful for every opportunity to educate customers and the trust and faith they have in her. She absolutely loves serving the families in her community and beyond.